26January
2026
Special City Council Meeting · One key issue

This special meeting was a work study on rewriting the ordinance that governs the city's Police Oversight Commission, and no vote was taken.

Check this moment · 1:09:03
3.3 hours 1 agenda items 1 located in video 59% attributed to a named speaker
Brief

What happened

Monday, January 26, 2026

  1. 01

    Only five of the seven members attended.

    1:08:42
  2. 02

    The commission works on an audit model, reviewing files after the fact rather than running its own investigations, and Councilmember Phan pressed on how narrow that makes it.

    1:47:16
    Explore this issue
    Related agenda item 1

    Police Oversight Commission Ordinance Work Study Session

    Open agenda item →

    What councilmembers said

    Representative transcript excerpts—not inferred positions.

    Sonia R. Carvalho
    Sonia R. CarvalhoCity Attorney

    Well, it was actually city manager office input, city attorney's office input. What happened at the time that we decided we were gonna review it is everyone took an independent review and look at it, and then we all came together and put all of our comments…

    2:19:22
    Thai Viet Phan
    Thai Viet PhanCouncilmember

    is also a public safety issue. There are a variety of priorities that we have to figure out in this city and this is one of those many priorities. So I think we just have to be honest with people to say if we are going to investigate, we can do one at a time…

    2:49:57
    Phil Bacerra
    Phil BacerraCouncilmember

    Councilman Becerra Thank you, Madam Mayor. I, too, want to express my appreciation for the clarity on the charter, because when we talk about legislative oversight, I feel like when I hear certain comments up here, It feels like there are commissioners that…

    3:09:57
    Valerie Amezcua
    Valerie AmezcuaMayor

    So when we talk about all the cases that we're paying out currently, there are cases that that as you had indicated, Jack, city manager, police chief, during the ad hoc we had talked about, it takes years for cases to settle. So, the previous chief, previous…

    3:09:05
  3. 03

    She was told the commission can only look at complaint files, so patterns like pedestrian stops fall outside what it can examine.

    1:49:05
    Explore this issue
    Related agenda item 1

    Police Oversight Commission Ordinance Work Study Session

    Open agenda item →

    What councilmembers said

    Representative transcript excerpts—not inferred positions.

    Sonia R. Carvalho
    Sonia R. CarvalhoCity Attorney

    Well, it was actually city manager office input, city attorney's office input. What happened at the time that we decided we were gonna review it is everyone took an independent review and look at it, and then we all came together and put all of our comments…

    2:19:22
    Thai Viet Phan
    Thai Viet PhanCouncilmember

    is also a public safety issue. There are a variety of priorities that we have to figure out in this city and this is one of those many priorities. So I think we just have to be honest with people to say if we are going to investigate, we can do one at a time…

    2:49:57
    Phil Bacerra
    Phil BacerraCouncilmember

    Councilman Becerra Thank you, Madam Mayor. I, too, want to express my appreciation for the clarity on the charter, because when we talk about legislative oversight, I feel like when I hear certain comments up here, It feels like there are commissioners that…

    3:09:57
    Valerie Amezcua
    Valerie AmezcuaMayor

    So when we talk about all the cases that we're paying out currently, there are cases that that as you had indicated, Jack, city manager, police chief, during the ad hoc we had talked about, it takes years for cases to settle. So, the previous chief, previous…

    3:09:05
  4. 04

    More than a dozen residents spoke first, most of them organised around strengthening the commission's powers, and one who spoke against.

    38:25
    Explore this issue
    Related agenda item 1

    Police Oversight Commission Ordinance Work Study Session

    Open agenda item →

    What councilmembers said

    Representative transcript excerpts—not inferred positions.

    Sonia R. Carvalho
    Sonia R. CarvalhoCity Attorney

    Well, it was actually city manager office input, city attorney's office input. What happened at the time that we decided we were gonna review it is everyone took an independent review and look at it, and then we all came together and put all of our comments…

    2:19:22
    Thai Viet Phan
    Thai Viet PhanCouncilmember

    is also a public safety issue. There are a variety of priorities that we have to figure out in this city and this is one of those many priorities. So I think we just have to be honest with people to say if we are going to investigate, we can do one at a time…

    2:49:57
    Phil Bacerra
    Phil BacerraCouncilmember

    Councilman Becerra Thank you, Madam Mayor. I, too, want to express my appreciation for the clarity on the charter, because when we talk about legislative oversight, I feel like when I hear certain comments up here, It feels like there are commissioners that…

    3:09:57
    Valerie Amezcua
    Valerie AmezcuaMayor

    So when we talk about all the cases that we're paying out currently, there are cases that that as you had indicated, Jack, city manager, police chief, during the ad hoc we had talked about, it takes years for cases to settle. So, the previous chief, previous…

    3:09:05
  5. 05

    The council asked the city attorney to come back in about three months with options, leaving the existing ordinance in force meanwhile.

    3:18:25
    Explore this issue
    Related agenda item 1

    Police Oversight Commission Ordinance Work Study Session

    Open agenda item →

    What councilmembers said

    Representative transcript excerpts—not inferred positions.

    Sonia R. Carvalho
    Sonia R. CarvalhoCity Attorney

    Well, it was actually city manager office input, city attorney's office input. What happened at the time that we decided we were gonna review it is everyone took an independent review and look at it, and then we all came together and put all of our comments…

    2:19:22
    Thai Viet Phan
    Thai Viet PhanCouncilmember

    is also a public safety issue. There are a variety of priorities that we have to figure out in this city and this is one of those many priorities. So I think we just have to be honest with people to say if we are going to investigate, we can do one at a time…

    2:49:57
    Phil Bacerra
    Phil BacerraCouncilmember

    Councilman Becerra Thank you, Madam Mayor. I, too, want to express my appreciation for the clarity on the charter, because when we talk about legislative oversight, I feel like when I hear certain comments up here, It feels like there are commissioners that…

    3:09:57
    Valerie Amezcua
    Valerie AmezcuaMayor

    So when we talk about all the cases that we're paying out currently, there are cases that that as you had indicated, Jack, city manager, police chief, during the ad hoc we had talked about, it takes years for cases to settle. So, the previous chief, previous…

    3:09:05
How this brief was made

The current summaries were prepared during an in-session review of the transcripts. This prototype shows only sentences with a timestamp citation. 0 uncited sentences were withheld from this page.

Agenda

Every item

1 items in agenda order

1
Work Study Session

Police Oversight Commission Ordinance Work Study Session

1:07:56
  • The oversight director presented options for rewriting the ordinance that sets what the Police Oversight Commission can and cannot do.1:09:03
  • Mayor Amezcua opened by correcting a claim made during public comment that the meeting had been called at short notice, and the city manager confirmed the direction to hold it dated back to the previous July.1:07:59
  • Councilmember Vazquez, who sat on the committee that worked on it, thanked staff for the work.1:41:37
  • The city attorney explained the charter lets the council create commissions like this one by ordinance, and change them the same way.1:46:19
  • Councilmember Phan said she understood why an audit model was chosen given limited time and resources, but wanted to know what it leaves out.1:47:16
  • She was told the commission's review is limited to complaint files, so it cannot examine broader patterns such as pedestrian stops.1:49:05
  • She confirmed with staff that this is narrower than what the oversight office would prefer.1:49:55
  • The city attorney asked for three months to bring back options, and said the current ordinance keeps operating until the council gives new direction.3:17:35
  • The mayor summed up the direction as bringing back the existing ordinance alongside what had been raised that night, rather than three or four competing versions.3:18:25
  • The city manager added that the commission's own proposed bylaws would come to the council on 3 February.3:18:41
Official agendaSupplied summaryClerk timestampCity Manager’s Office
Official recommendation
  1. Maintain the current ordinance while including clean up language to align with the City Charter and have the Independent Oversight Director be appointed by the City Manager, remain independent from the Police Department, and still vetted by the City Council
  2. Modify the existing ordinance to the staff recommended audit model
  3. Modify the existing ordinance to a hybrid audit/investigation model, reflecting input from the Police Oversight Commission, and recommend that officer involved shootings and use of force that cause great bodily harm are open to investigation at the direction of the commission
Full transcript

Read or search the complete meeting

502 merged speaker turns are available in a dedicated reading view. It opens with unidentified speech hidden.

Open transcript

Agenda location